I was looking at NamUs’s newly added cases and saw one for a guy named Eddie Vanneiter. I knew I had an Edward Vannater on Charley and so I pulled him up, thinking they must be the same guy, just with slightly different names. But clearly they aren’t.
Edward vanished from Ohio in 2003; Eddie disappeared from Florida in 2000. Edward was 32; Eddie was 26. Etc. Edward is white; Eddie is black and, from what the details of disappearance says, probably a resident of the Dutch Caribbean island of Curaçao. (If he was, he’d be the first Curaçaoan on Charley.)
It reminds me of back in the MPCCN days when the site featured two people named Carlina Francher. If I recall correctly, only did they share the same first and last names, they were also African-American teenage girls missing from New York City.
I’ll add Eddie…well…whenever. I can’t really promise to add anyone at any particular time because I’ve got so many cases in the inbox it’s ridiculous.
The Charley Project Blog 
Reminds me of two stories of murders/murder victims that are often confused with each – Romona Moore and Ramona Moore
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Romona_Moore
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramona_Moore_murder_case
Are you sure they weren’t killed by a Terminator trying to prevent the birth of some future resistance leader?
That’s…an interesting theory. Never thought about it that way, but yes, the very similar names and the fact that both girls were black and young provides plenty of space for Terminator-like theories.
Eddie is almost definitely this john doe:
http://www.doenetwork.org/cases/945umpa.html
I called it in the day his casefile showed up in NamUs.