This week’s featured MP is Beatrice Marie Lopez Cubelos, who disappeared from Albuquerque, New Mexico in the early morning hours of September 24, 1989. She decided not to wait on a ride home from a friend, and to hitchhike instead. She never made it.
Offhand, I wonder if Beatrice might have been one of the victims of David Parker Ray. She disappeared in his territory.
This week’s Flashback Friday case is Patricia Joan Chesher, aka Patty, a twelve-year-old girl who disappeared while selling raffle tickets door-to-door in Albuquerque, New Mexico on June 17, 1969.
There’s a lot to unpack here. The NCMEC classifies her as a runaway, but given her age and the passage of time, foul play seems more likely. There are a few persons of interest: a neighbor who bought one of the raffle tickets, her older sister’s boyfriend who had mental problems, a creepy uncle.
In any case, after 47 years I doubt this case can be solved.
I managed to squeeze her in at 11:00 p.m.: Alesha Brookshier, missing from the town of Farmington in the northwest corner of New Mexico since September 28, 2008. She was 37 years old and owned a tanning business in Farmington, although she lived in nearby Atzec.
Although Alesha spoke to her sister just about every day prior to her disappearance, she wasn’t reported missing for ages. Alesha’s ex-husband never reported her missing. Her sister says she notified police six months later, but there’s no record of a report then either. One of Alesha’s cousins finally got the ball rolling eighteen months after she was last seen.
It isn’t clear what happened to this woman, although her ex-husband was charged with forgery and fraud after he cashed a $2,200 paycheck made out to her. Her ex-husband cashed another of her paychecks, worth $1,000, as well. He deposited the money in her account but withdrew it all for himself within a few days. Which doesn’t necessarily mean he’s responsible for his disappearance, but it does prove he’s dishonest and a thief.
Another possible indication of foul play: sometime in 2009 Alesha’s car was found burned in her hometown of Aztec.
I have more info on her case than I do on a lot of them, but it’s all rather vague. I wish I had more details.
As for me: I saw my family doctor this morning and she gave me a clean bill of health, and as for insurance etc the situation is not as dire as it appeared yesterday. (See my comment on another entry about what I learned from the police report on Monday.) I’ve been out most of the day, and when I got home I had a friend over for dinner and we watched the VP debate. I plan to fully return to work tomorrow.
Robin Warder (who does that Trail Went Cold podcast I wrote about not too long ago) did an MP-related Cracked article that got published yesterday: The 5 Most Insane Twist Endings Of Real Missing Person Cases. Included was the case of Bobby Dunbar, who was “found” in 1912 but is actually still missing (long story). I thought I’d let y’all know about this article. Like most Cracked articles it’s interesting, informative and funny.
Incidentally, the most recent podcast for The Trail Went Cold is for two Catholic priests, father Reynoldo Rivera and Father John Kerrigan. The former was the victim of a horrific murder; the latter disappeared and was never found but was almost certainly also murdered. Both cases remain unsolved. There’s some speculation that the cases are related, although the murder happened in New Mexico and the disappearance in Montana. Father Kerrigan had spent some time in New Mexico, and in both cases, it seemed like whoever did this had a serious grudge against the church.
I actually updated Father Kerrigan’s casefile last month, with some significant new information. (I found out he was accused of sexual abuse.) I wonder if it’s a coincidence, then, that Warder did this podcast now. I haven’t listened to the podcast yet so I don’t know.
Podcasts are fun and entertaining, and I highly recommend them to true crime buffs, but unless I have some time to kill, I usually don’t listen to them myself. If I’m already familiar with the case, a podcast usually just provides a few shreds of extra info for the most part, or sometimes nothing at all. It would take much less time to read an article about the case and those often have more info in them. I wish more podcast included the written text as well as the recording.
I stumbled across the Bernalillo County, NM sheriff’s office website today; they have several cold cases listed. Specifically, they’ve got thirteen pages of both homicides and MPs. I found additional information about several MPs I already have on Charley, PLUS two MPs I’d never heard of before. Neither of them are listed on either NamUs or New Mexico’s state missing persons database. Although I wish the sheriff’s office MP profiles would provide physical descriptions of the missing, they’ve got photos and some details of the circumstances and it’s a start, at least.
Sharon M. emailed me and asked me to run Edyth Warner or her son Nicholas Smith for Select It Sunday. They both disappeared at the same time and since last week’s SIS was a male and I try to alternate genders each week, I’m going to do Edyth.
Edyth a student at New Mexico State University, studying art, when she and her son disappeared without a trace in 1991. (Sharon M. was also a student at NMSU at the same time, but didn’t personally know Edyth or her family.) Her focus was working with metal, in particular jewelry-making. She lived with Nicholas and her husband, Henry, and her other son in housing for married students. Nicholas was her son by a prior relationship; the younger boy was Henry and Edyth’s child.
Henry (more about him later) didn’t help by not reporting his wife and stepson’s disappearances for two weeks — he claims the NMSU police refused to accept a report sooner. Maybe they didn’t. That sounds depressingly believable to me. But if Edyth really did take $11,000 worth of cash and gold coins when she disappeared, the delay in reporting would be understandable.
That is, IF that’s what happened.
And there’s a lot of suspicion now about Edyth’s husband. They were in the process of a divorce in 1991, and after Edyth and Nicholas disappeared, Henry divorced Edyth in absentia and wouldn’t let Edyth’s parents have any contact with their other grandson. But there’s no hard evidence to implicate him that I know of.
Another indication that Edyth didn’t leave on her own: there were no requests for Nicholas’s school to forward his records on somewhere else. That’s pretty telling.
Edyth’s younger son would now be grown up. I hope he’s been in touch with his maternal grandparents by now.
This week’s Select It Sunday case, chosen by Sabrina, is Anthonette Cayedito. Now, for some reason, as I type this the Charley Project doesn’t seem to be working right now, but hopefully it will be back up again shortly.
Anthonette is of Native American and Italian descent. She was last seen at her home in Gallup, New Mexico in the wee hours of April 6, 1986. She was nine years old. A man who claimed to be her uncle — but wasn’t — dragged her into a vehicle and drove away.
There is some evidence that Anthonette survived for a time after her abduction, and I suppose she could still be alive even now, but the police don’t seem to think so.
The case seems very strange to me. Why did a nine-year-old girl answer the front door at three o’clock in the morning? Why did an adult not do it?