This just really makes me mad

On the first of this month, NamUs added the case of Emmanuel Birts, a five-week-old baby who’s been missing from Dallas, Texas since 1989. Their casefile provided no details about his disappearance. I did my usual info-checking and found a number of articles that mention the case. I found four or five from the time the abduction happened, and one from several months later that was about another missing baby but mentioned Emmanuel’s abduction in passing. This is my draft thus far of the summary that’s going to appear on Charley when I put up Emmanuel’s casefile:

Emmanuel was born at his grandmother’s Dallas, Texas home, but spent seven days at Parkland Memorial Hospital after birth. He was released from the hospital on August 11, 1989 and went to live with with his grandmother, Hermane Grady, and mother, Kisha Birts, in the 2900 block of east Ledbetter Drive. His abductor, who claimed to be a social worker and called herself Debra Manning, first visited the home on August 12, saying she was making a follow-up home visit from the hospital. She told them Emmanuel had an eye infection, which was in fact true.

Manning visited the family again on September 12, and claimed there was a possibility Emmanuel was infected with the HIV virus. Because Kisha had used drugs during her pregnancy, this was plausible. On the evening of September 13, Manning visted again, with a letter she claimed was from the Child Welfare Department. The letter said Emmanuel needed to go to the hospital and get tested for HIV. She said she needed to take the baby immediately, and Kisha wanted to come with them, but Manning made an excuse as to why she couldn’t, and said she’d come pick up Emmanuel for the test the next morning.

On the morning of September 14, Kisha went to Parkland Memorial Hospital to ask about her baby’s health. She left Emmanuel home with Grady. When Manning first arrived, she claimed she had to get a car seat for the baby and would be back in an hour. She did return and Grady let her take Emmanuel with her at 10:00 a.m. She promised to return by 2:00 p.m. Manning never returned with the baby and neither of them have ever been seen again. The family reported Emmanuel missing at 8:00 p.m.

The abductor is described as African-American, in her thirties, 5’6 tall and 145 pounds. Her hair appeared to be sandy brown, although it may have been a wig. She wore heavy blue eyeshadow and spoke with a foreign accent, possibly of African origin. She claimed to own a van, although none of Emmanuel’s family members saw any vehicle. The name Debra Manning was almost certainly an alias, although Grady actually did know a welfare worker by that name. Child Protective Services hadn’t authorized Emmanuel’s removal from his home for any reason. The abductor always wore a white lab coat and surgical pants; real social workers wore street clothes. Investigators believe the abductor may have a history as a con artist, given the nature of Emmanuel’s abduction. She apparently also had access to the baby’s medical information.

Both of Emmanuel’s parents subsequently tested negative for HIV. They also took polygraph exams and neither of them are considered suspects in the child’s abduction. The woman who called herself Debra Manning has never been identified and there’s been no sign of either her or Emmanuel since the day she took him away in 1989. His case remains unsolved.

What. The. Beep.

Where has this case been all this time? Why have I never heard of it before? Why hasn’t Emmanuel been listed with the NCMEC? Why hasn’t there been anything in the press about it since nineteen-fracking-ninety? Where has everyone BEEN?

11 thoughts on “This just really makes me mad

  1. Christy April 11, 2014 / 11:55 pm

    The Namus casefile says this baby is female.

  2. Brenda Overton Hayes April 11, 2014 / 11:55 pm

    wow this is really amazing so there is a missing child but no one seems to really care its like they just came in swooped up the kid and are getting away scott free?????? this is scary actually!!!

  3. Princess Shantae April 12, 2014 / 7:17 am

    And why does namus bother to even list this case if it 1. Can’t get his sex right and 2. didn’t include info that your average person can find online? Why do they bother?

    • Meaghan April 12, 2014 / 8:10 am

      NamUs isn’t big on listing details. Many of their casefiles have little or nothing under “circumstances.” It’s just the way they are.

  4. mels April 12, 2014 / 11:26 am

    reminds me of kamiyah mobley. have you ever read anything suggesting her abductor had an accent?

    of course, accents can be put on, or lost over time. the descriptions of the abductors in both cases are pretty similar.

  5. Holly April 12, 2014 / 8:37 pm

    This is just crazy. I feel almost certain it was someone who 1) wanted a baby 2) was selling babies on some type of black market. It’s unfortunate that there are cases that just get no attention, no publicity – those are the most heartbreaking to me. He would be a young man now; hopefully, happy somewhere.

  6. aphra75 April 13, 2014 / 8:25 pm

    this reminds me of Melissa Highsmith’s case, too, a little. She went missing from the Dallas/Fort Worth area too, albeit many years before Emmanuel.

  7. Kat April 16, 2014 / 10:31 am

    Thought this case sounded familiar, then I came across David Blockett’s case. It’s awful close. Baby ring maybe?

    • Meaghan April 18, 2014 / 8:12 am

      They’re like a thousand miles apart though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s